GAMBLING WITH GAMBLING: A NO-WIN BET
Anonymous
Writer’s comment: I
have always believed that one should learn from their mistakes. I have
made many mistakes in my life, and gambling is perhaps the biggest one
of all. Indeed, I have learned from my experiences. Looking back, I
wish I had never gotten involved with gambling. Now, I only hope that
my experiences can deter others from gambling. For over a year,
Congress has debated the issue of online gambling: whether to ban it
completely, regulate it, or leave it unregulated as it is now. I hope
that somehow my paper will find its way into the hands of Congress.
Perhaps they will realize that the well-being of their constituents far
exceeds the importance of campaign contributions and choose to prevent
others from the agony that I and millions of others have gone through.
- Student Writer
Instructor’s comment: The student wrote his essay as a sophomore
in English 19: Writing Research Papers. It is a personal research essay—well
researched, strongly analytical, and seriously personal. But the essay did
not begin as a personal essay—far from it—and I think that other writers
may be encouraged to realize that strong personal writing does not always
begin with subjective writing. In the weeks prior to his rough draft, hehad
maintained an impersonal and strongly argumentative stand on gambling as
he wrote other, short papers on the topic. Then, as he worked on his long
draft, other students in class responded to his ideas and were very interested
in his tentative personal anecdotes. They encouraged him to make his connection
to the topic explicit. From major rewriting emerged this fascinating and
very effective essay, in which social and personal analysis intertwine.
- Susan Palo, English Department
Hi, my name is ______ and
this is my first GamAnon meeting. I am nineteen years old, and I
started gambling in junior high, $5 bets with friends. In high school,
craps and deuces were the craze. The teachers had no idea. Then I
started playing the lottery, hoping to hit the jackpot. Age never
really mattered since the vendor never asked to see ID. In my first
year of college, I started wagering on sporting events through an
online sports book. It was completely legal, even though I was only 18
years old. I have always loved sports and having money on a game made
it even more fun, more exciting. At first, it was only $25 or $50 a
game, but then things got out of control: I was laying hundreds of
dollars on single games. It wasn’t fun anymore. My bank account
dwindled from four figures to two. My GPA was half my high school 4.0+.
I knew I had a problem, but I just couldn’t stop, no matter how hard I
tried. That’s why I’m here today. I need help.
I never thought that a friendly wager could lead to such
self-destructive behavior. Luckily, I recognized that I had a gambling
problem and sought help, unlike the millions of other pathological
gamblers who allow their problems to worsen, some eventually becoming
involved with drugs, alcohol, and crime (Lesieur 43). Annually,
Americans legally wager over five hundred billion dollars—more than
they spend on groceries—and illegally bet hundreds of billions more
(Reno 43).
Pathological gambling as a national problem did not emerge
until the early 1970s. Since then, the number of pathological gamblers
steadily increased—until around 1988 when they began to multiply. What
led millions like me to start gambling? Psychologists and psychiatrists
provide the traditional and widely accepted explanation: individuals
are driven to gamble by certain personal psychological factors. This
explanation, however, was applied to pathological gambling well before
the recent surge of the 1970s; therefore, while this explanation may
explain why any given individual may become a pathological gambler, it
cannot explain why so many people became pathological gamblers during
this time period. Other non-psychological changes must have facilitated
increased gambling: technological advancements, new modes of
communications, increased media coverage, and other societal factors.
The Pathological Gambler
The severity of the gambling problem varies; pathological
gamblers must be distinguished from recreational gamblers —such as
those who occasionally purchase a lottery ticket. The American
Psychiatric Association defines pathological gambling as “chronic and
progressive failure to resist impulses to gamble, and gambling behavior
that compromises, disrupts, or damages personal, family, or vocational
pursuits” (APA 324). Pathological gamblers characteristically become
preoccupied with gambling—gambling with increasing amounts of money,
trying to win back past losses—ultimately leading to personal and
financial ruin. These characteristics, along with other notable traits
of pathological gamblers, are identified in the American Psychiatric
Association publication Diagnostic and Statistical Manual III-Revised (DSM-III-R).
Before encountering the DSM-III-R,I did not think I had
a gambling problem; I told myself that I was only a recreational
gambler. As I read through the list of traits, I identified with more
and more characteristics. I had become consumed by gambling, planning
my next wagers, re-living past victories in my mind while agonizing
over costly losses. As time progressed, so did my gambling problem. I
began to wager not only more money, but also on more games. I wanted to
quit—but only after I recovered the money already lost—further
plummeting myself into debt. Between school and gambling, there was no
contest. My GPA plummeted to a wee 2.10. Only after a quarter-long
hiatus from gambling—simply because I had run out of money with which
to gamble—and a 4.0 for the quarter, could I raise my cumulative GPA to
a more respectable 3.0. The hiatus, however, was not permanent. Still,
I did not realize I was a pathological gambler until I sifted through
the DSM-III-R.
History and Current State of Gambling
Gambling has existed since the beginning of time, with the
Bible making references to its existence (Simon 8). The Greeks told
myths about the seductiveness of gambling, while the Romans placed
wagers on the fifty chariot races that were run each day. Gambling
surfaced early in United States history; during the colonial period,
lotteries were held in Jamestown—the first colonial settlement (McGowan
3). Now, centuries later, gambling has become an epidemic afflicting
many Americans, regardless of gender, age, class, and race.
Since 1974, numerous studies and surveys have assessed the
magnitude of pathological gambling. Results and statistics indicate
that gambling today is remarkably more prevalent than at previous
times, as well as more widespread. Between 1974 and 1989, the total
amount wagered annually by Americans grew an astounding 1400 percent,
from $17.4 billion to $247 billion (Lesieur 43). A more recent study
estimated that the dollar amount of legal wagers made by Americans in
1993 was approximately $395 billion, with another $120 billion in
illegal wagers (“Betting Odds” S8). Just three years later, this figure
soared to $550 billion, nearly a forty percent increase. Revenues
generated by gambling now exceed the revenues from movies, spectator
sports, recorded music, theme parks, and cruise ships combined(Koughan 32).
Not only have there been increases in the total amounts being
wagered, but also in the number of pathological gamblers. As of 1995,
only two studies and one poll had tried to quantify the number of
pathological gamblers on a national level. The results of one study,
performed in 1974, showed that 61 percent of the United States
population had gambled. A Gallup poll, conducted by one of the nation’s
renowned accounting firms in 1989, concluded that the proportion of the
population who had gambled had increased to 81 percent. In addition,
the Gallup poll found that about 30 percent of adults gambled on a
weekly basis (Layden 71). More recently, a 1994 study suggested that
approximately 10.5 million Americans suffer some form of gambling
problem—an estimate based upon a regional sample population (Simon 9).
Traditional Theories
Traditional theories attribute pathological gambling
behavior to the gambler’s personal psychological factors. Psychologists
and psychiatrists alike suggest that the majority of pathological
gamblers begin gambling during their adolescent years or after a major
life stress, such as the death of a parent (Griffiths 42). Traumatic
events may lead an emotionally unstable person to escape and seek
refuge from reality through gambling. People are most susceptible to
excessive gambling during their adolescent years, when they are most
likely to encounter family problems — such as their parents’ divorce —
a lack of discipline or schooling, and exposure to gambling, perhaps by
other family members or friends. Other predisposing factors of
pathological gamblers include an above average IQ, a low threshold for
boredom, a tendency to take risks, and a workaholic mentality
(Griffiths 8).
Many psychologists and psychiatrists also postulate that
gambling is a learned activity, an idea first developed by Sigmund
Freud. It is believed that playing games during early childhood
actually serves as training for future gambling behavior. In his
article “Gambling Swindles and Victims,” Snyder observes that in
childhood games that result in winners and losers, the common prize is
status, rather than some material gain (54). In games that involve
gambling, such as marbles or card flipping, children are exposed to the
concept of risk: by taking risks, children build their reputations as
winners and receive social rewards (Griffiths 43). Some carry these
childhood experiences through adolescence, causing them to seek out
gambling as a way of attaining social standing.
These traditional theories, however, were formulated,
developed, and applied to pathological gambling several decades before
the gambling rates soared. The psychological factors described also
existed prior to 1974 and yet gambling had not been as substantial or
widespread. What, then, caused millions of Americans to become
pathological gamblers after 1974?
Societal Factors
The growth of pathological gambling after 1974 is directly
related to social changes. Various studies have shown that increases in
gambling opportunities often result in increases in the gambling rate;
where gambling is permitted and legal, a greater proportion of the
population exhibit gambling behavior (Griffiths 3; Devlin and Peppard
904; Lesieur 43).
The post-1974 period is marked by the widespread acceptance
and approval of gambling at all levels of the government, state and
federal. The most common form of gambling allowed is the state-run
lottery. After 1893, all sales of lottery tickets were prohibited by
federal statute, but as states developed dire needs for revenue,
lotteries crept back into existence (Reno 43). Only 2 states operated
lotteries in 1970; by 1994, 38 states conducted lotteries (Sandel 27).
In that year, $34 billion was spent on lottery tickets — as compared to
$9 billion in 1985 — garnering over $12 billion in total revenues for
various government treasuries (McGowan xi). In the United States today, all but two of the fifty states — Hawaii and Utah — allow some form of gambling.
By offering lotteries, states contribute to increasing the
population of gamblers. Studies reveal that a majority of those who
participate in lotteries become involved in other forms of gambling
(Devlin and Peppard 905; Frank 909). States, however, choose to
disregard these findings; state-run lotteries require that participants
need only be 18 years old, even though the minimum legal gambling age
is 21 years. Not only do states offer lotteries, but they also heavily
promote their lotteries. Each year, the states combined spend over $350
million on lottery advertisements (Reno 43), enhancing the general
social acceptance of gambling. Recent trends also favor legalization of
Indian gaming and casino gambling, as well as riverboat gambling.
In addition to the government, sports media have also catered
to the needs of gamblers. Betting information can be found in nearly
all newspapers, from the widely read newspapers to the small local
newspapers. Every day, the sports section offers varied up-to-date
information used by gamblers to select their wagers. Aside from listing
betting lines and odds for virtually all the day’s sporting events, the
typical sports section also provides injury reports, trades and
transactions, roster changes, and statistics—more information than the
average sports fan wants, or needs, to know (“Betting Odds” S6).
Sports broadcasting also shares responsibility in the growth
of gambling. Like the question “Which came first, the chicken or the
egg?” a similar question can be asked of sports gambling and sports
programming on cable and satellite television (McGraw 50). Gamblers can
now wager on and watch any sporting event they desire; even a college
basketball game between Quinnipiac College and Austin Peay State
University is accessible through satellite coverage.
Conclusion
Initially, I doubted that my gambling was provoked by
psychological factors, but after thinking about my childhood, I found
it plausible. At the time I began to gamble, my parents often engaged
in loud shouting matches as I lay in bed, crying and wishing they would
stop. Making matters worse, my grandfather—who raised me, as a child,
in Thailand—came to visit and passed away unexpectedly here in the
United States. I was devastated, sad, and alone. But, to escape
reality, why would I turn to gambling, instead of alcohol or drugs or
suicide?
These psychological factors were merely “push” factors,
factors that push an individual towards an outlet from reality. Which
outlet one chooses, then, depends on the “pull” factors. In my case, I
was “pulled” — or drawn — towards gambling, finding hope in playing the
lottery, aroused by the excitement of watching a game I wagered on. A
combination of “push” (psychological) factors and “pull” (societal)
factors, which did not exist prior to 1974, then sufficiently explains
the rise of pathological gambling in recent decades.
Members of GamAnon enter a 12-step recovery program. The
first step is to recognize and admit that a gambling problem exists. In
the process of writing this research paper, I was not only able to
realize and accept that I had a gambling problem, but I was also able
to determine why I developed the gambling habits. Perhaps the next
paper you read by me will describe the 12-step recovery process and my
continued abstinence from gambling.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. (3rd Ed. revised). Washington D.C.: 1987.
“Betting Odds: News or Not? Sports Betting and the Media.” American Journalism Review 17 (1995): S4-S8.
Devlin, Ann Sloan and Donald M. Peppard. “Casino Use by College Students.” Psychological Reports 78 (1996): 899-906.
Frank, Michael L. “Underage Gambling in Atlantic City Casinos.” Psychological Reports 67 (1990): 907-912.
Griffiths, Mark. Adolescent Gambling. New York: Routledge, 1995.
Koughan, Martin. “Easy Money.” Mother Jones. July 1997: 32-37.
Layden, Tim. “Bettor Education.” Sports Illustrated. April 3, 1995: 68-83.
Lesieur, Henry R. “Compulsive Gambling.” Society. May 1992: 43-50.
McGowan, Richard. State Lotteries and Legalized Gambling. Westport: Quorum, 1994.
McGraw, Dan. “The National Bet: Laying an Illegal Wager Has Never Been Easier.” U.S. News and World Report. April 7, 1997: 50-56.
Reno, Paul. “The Diceman Cometh.” Policy Review 76 (1996): 40-46.
Sandel, Michael J. “Bad Bet.” New Republic 216 (1997): 27.
Simon, Paul. “The Destructive Side of Gambling Mania.” St. Louis Journalism Review 26 (1995): 8-11.
Snyder, R.J. “Gambling Swindles and Victims.” Journal of Gambling Behavior 2 (1986): 50-57.