GARY SNYDER: POET AS PEDAGOGUE
Nancy Lo
Writer’s comment:
When we were assigned a profile article in my English 103C class, I
knew I wanted to focus on a writer since that’s the profession I want
to pursue. Gary Snyder’s name immediately popped into my head because
I’d heard a lot of good things about him and wanted to get to know him
and his work better. The fact that Snyder writes nature poetry also
attracted me because of my love for the outdoors.
Most of the pieces I had read about Snyder focused on his
poetry and his environmental activism. So I thought it would be both
interesting and different to center the piece around Snyder’s role as a
teacher. Even though I was terribly intimidated at first—so much that,
had it not been for Jayne Walker’s encouragement I would never have
written this piece—I found Snyder to be a very friendly and
approachable person. This piece was a great learning experience for me
because I discovered the rewards of confronting your fears and going
out on a limb. Thank you, Gary.
—Nancy Lo
Instructor’s comment: The profile is the most
demanding assignment in my English 103C (Article Writing) classes.
Weeks before the first draft is due, the students begin discussing
possible subjects and analyzing a variety of models. Journal
assignments guide them through the preparatory steps Helen Benedict
advocates in her indispensible book Portraits in Print: researching
printed sources, preparing long lists of interview questions,
contacting other people who could shed some light on the principal
subject.
Nancy's preparatory work was brilliant and remarkably
thorough—except for one crucial omission: she couldn't bring herself to
contact Gary Snyder to set up an appointment. The other students tried
to help her overcome her fear. I remember an art history major telling
her how helpful and cooperative Wayne Thibaud had been when she
interviewed him a few days before. Finally, Nancy screwed up her
courage and made an appointment. But before their meeting, to keep on
schedule, she had already written a complete draft based on her reading
and interviews with other faculty members and students. I'm convinced
that the richness of Nancy's final version owes a great deal to the
extraordinary amount of work—both research and writing—she did before
she ever interviewed her subject.
—Jayne Walker, English Department
People spilling into the
aisles of Kleiber Hall were evidence enough of Gary Snyder’s
popularity. A diverse audience waited to hear him read from his newest
work, No Nature. Next to me sat an older man, and hairy-legged
women and bandanna-and-flannel-shirt-wearing college boys were
scattered throughout the hall. After squeezing myself into a spot on
the steps of the first row, I looked to my right and wondered, “Is that
him?” He looked like a Gary Snyder—the years of wisdom,
experience, and spirituality etched in every wrinkle and freckle of his
weathered face, his salt-and-pepper beard a product of careful neglect.
He sported a shirt, tie, and blazer coupled with blue jeans and cowboy
boots. A stud earring in his left ear provided the finishing touch to
his distinct look. Obviously pleased with the turnout, he joked, “This
is an amazing turnout, considering it’s not required.” The audience
chuckled appreciatively. As he began reading, images of nature, family,
religion, folklore, and animals clung to the air of the crowded hall.
Everyone writes about Gary Snyder the “eco poet” and
environmental crusader. Most articles focus on the fact that he speaks
flawless Chinese and Japanese, spent many years in Japan studying and
practicing Zen Buddhism (a belief that now plays a large part in his
life), lives in a self-designed-and-built log cabin nestled in the
Sierra Nevada foothills near Nevada City, and that he’s written fifteen
volumes of poetry and prose, one of which won him a Pulitzer Prize in
1975. But how many people know about Gary Snyder the teacher?
In his classes at UC Davis, Snyder focuses on his loves:
poetry, nature, and spirituality. Since joining the English
Department’s Creative Writing Program in 1986, he has taught a graduate
poetry workshop, an advanced seminar on wilderness literature, a
seminar on West Coast Poetry and the Beats, and a creative writing
class focusing on poetry. Snyder says, “I’m lucky enough to be allowed
by the University to teach courses in areas that I’m curious about.”
According to his friend and colleague English professor
Jack Hicks, getting Snyder to commit to a professorship was quite an
involved process. But persistence eventually paid off; Hicks, with a
few instrumental grad students, convinced Snyder to officially sign on.
The deal proved fruitful since he no longer had to worry about
financial stability and could concentrate on writing.
Even though he has a successful writing career, Snyder
never neglects his commitment to students and the University. When I
ask Professor Peter Dale, Chair of the English Department, to comment
on Snyder’s teaching, he kids, “I’ve never taken a class from him,” and
then continues more seriously, “He would be a very wise person to learn
from. He is deeply committed to literature and the preservation of the
environment. Students need to know about these things.”
In Gary Snyder: Dimensions of a Life, Hicks
emphasizes that unlike “some noted writers [who] rent their names to
colleges, Snyder works the job here—he is diligent with his courses.”
Hicks explains to me that Snyder’s “teaching is an absolute role to
him. It’s part of his own development; the process of teaching is a way
of altering, nourishing that [process] of writing.” When I relay Hicks’
observation, Snyder agrees. “I certainly approach teaching as a
learning process.”
One reason Snyder came to Davis was to begin an
interdisciplinary program in Nature and Culture that “seeks to find and
nourish deep affinities between scientists, humanists, and writers.” He
has played a vital role in initiating this innovative major: “I noticed
that a number of faculty in the English Department and people from
other departments knew about [different aspects of nature] but we never
got together and talked. So I organized a little meeting where we
talked and shared ideas. I decided that we should pool our resources,
and it has now become an accepted program that’s going to start in the
spring.” He clearly values this project: “I have a feeling that doing
work like this Nature and Culture program is really what I came to
Davis for.”
The aura of this famous poet is inescapable when you
write about Snyder. One of his students dramatically says, “When I’m a
grandmother, I’ll be able to say I took this intensive poetry writing
workshop with Gary Snyder.”
Another student describes him as “this wise old sage, very learned,
very inspiring.” English professor David Van Leer sums it all up by
saying, “He’s beyond famous; he’s mythic.”
Snyder’s fame sometimes hinders his teaching. “The
problem—if there is a problem—is that, because he’s so well-known a
figure, his undergraduate classes are filled beyond capacity,” says
Dale. “So it makes it hard for him to minister to the needs of each
individual student. But I think he does as much as he can.” One of his
students says, “Sometimes the stuff he tells us is so overwhelming,”
and another student admits that Snyder intimidated her at first, but
“after a while, you get used to him.”
Snyder’s presence and accessibility at UC Davis more than
compensate for any difficulties that arise. As one student convincingly
points out, “He’s available to us; we can just go to his office hours
and talk to him like a regular person without having to make an
appointment with his publisher or something.” As a prominent poetic
figure, Snyder encourages students as well as faculty to open their
minds and expose themselves to the wonders of poetry.
Teaching is a give-and-take process for Snyder. He says,
“I try to use the courses as a way to extend my own education. My
Literature of the Wilderness class directly informed and helped me
finish up my book of essays called Practice of the Wild.
That writing was clearly improved, informed and influenced by my
teaching.” When asked what else he gets out of teaching, Snyder
responds, “Being around students is interesting, and I get a sense of
where students’ concerns are. Also fascinating is the diversity of the
students—right now in my class there are three people who are not
native speakers of the English language. It’s wonderful to have people
from different backgrounds writing contemporary poetry. We’re going to
see more of that in the future.”
Studying and living in Japan has given Snyder a unique
perspective on teaching. “One of the useful aspects of me as a teacher
is, paradoxically, that I was not teaching for many years. For thirty
years I was on the outside, and so there are some strengths that come
from living outside of the university, living for a long time in Asia,
living as a working writer without the benefit of the university as an
umbrella. I speak like a working person from the outside who has seen a
lot of different ways of doing things. For a Zen Buddhism class I
taught, I brought in paintings, scrolls, calligraphy, and Japanese and
Chinese books because I wanted students to get the feel for some of
that stuff—details, artifacts, the way the incense smells—and get a
feel for what the practice of Buddhism in the temples is like.”
In his poetry workshop, Snyder offers advice to students
aspiring to become masterful poets. “He told us to ‘approach poetry
with juice,’ meaning that he knows you’ll be working on [your poetry] a
long time; it’s not quick, so you should be loose with yourself and at
first just let it all flow. But then you can be critical later.”
Another student insists I include the fact that “Snyder teaches us how
to think like poets [by] concentrat[ing] on how to mentally be a poet
instead of the mechanics of writing a poem.”
When I sit in on his poetry workshop, I discover for
myself what kind of teacher Snyder is. Shirt sleeves rolled up, he
waves his weathered hands as he talks. Although he’s soft spoken, he
nevertheless commands attention. His students aren’t intimidated and
speak freely. One student concludes that poets and creative people are
“screwed up and dysfunctional,” to which Snyder just laughs; he doesn’t
seem the least bit upset. As I continue to observe the class, I
discover that Snyder has an interesting mannerism. When students read
their poems aloud, he mouths the words of the poem along with them.
It’s as though he tries to get into the rhythm of the poem by reading
the words in addition to listening to them.
Snyder continually experiments with new styles of
teaching. “I’ve never found a set formula by which I could teach
poetry. I’m never entirely sure what works and what doesn’t work, so
I’m always watching and trying different things,” he explains. Hicks
told me, “He’s really good at setting up interesting, intriguing
situations so that students can talk, debate, hammer out things amongst
themselves. He’s particularly good at making very complex
issues—spirituality, politics, psychology—understandable without being
simplistic.” Hicks thinks that Snyder’s ability to make students think
for themselves furthers his success as a teacher.
Snyder lends flavor and depth to his lectures by sharing
interesting anecdotes and rele-vant facts. He constantly relates themes
in the poetry and students’ comments to his life’s experiences. When I
mention this observation, Snyder thoughtfully responds, “I have a broad
background and have kept in touch with many threads of
thought—philosophical, literary, political, spiritual, practical—over
the years, so I try to bring as much of that whole range of information
and insight to bear as I can on any given topic. Sometimes that means
that I may stop and take a turn when I’m giving a class—something like
the original botany of Yolo County or how a Chinese or Japanese
cultural perspective would see something that we’re talking about—it’s
those things coming up from time to time that [are out of the ordinary
and] make teaching more interesting for me.”
Snyder doesn’t stop teaching when he leaves the
classroom. He travels widely three or four months every year, visiting
universities, reading poems and lecturing, leading workshops and
seminars, participating in conferences and working closely with
environmental groups and indigenous peoples. Hicks admires Snyder’s
ability to “recognize the kind of format expected of him and click
right into that, whether he’s giving a speech in front of a large
dignified audience or talking in a smaller group.”
As the interview came to a close, Snyder said something
to which I could really relate: “I’m interested in making a way of
seeing a future California, or United States if you like, in which
cultural diversity is appreciated but also in the process everybody
from all different backgrounds should get to know the landscape. I want
to get Asian Americans and Black Americans equally involved in looking
at the landscape and getting out in it.
So I want to get all you guys out in the wilderness!” When he said
that, it brought everything into perspective for me: his love of
nature, his poetry, and his role as a teacher. What Snyder gives to his
students is not only an appreciation of poetry but an equally important
awareness of wilderness and the natural world.